Checking AI-generated content for accuracy
AI can produce convincing answers that aren't always correct. It might misinterpret a question or rely on outdated information, which could cause problems if you use its advice to manage an employee.
For example, you might ask AI to explain your responsibilities when an employee requests flexible working. If it relies on outdated guidance, it could incorrectly tell you that employees need 26 weeks' service before making a statutory request when actually employees have had the right to request flexible working from their first day of employment since April 2024.
Tip: Always check AI-generated advice against current guidance from Acas or GOV.uk before making HR decisions.
Keeping people responsible for HR decisions
AI can help you assess information, but employers should always be responsible for any decisions that affect their employees. This is particularly important when using AI to screen job applicants or assess someone's suitability for a role.
In November 2024, the Information Commissioner's Office (ICO) made almost 300 recommendations following audits of AI recruitment tools, highlighting concerns about how employers process candidates' personal information.
The Data (Use and Access) Act 2025 also updated the UK's rules on automated decision-making. Where the rules apply, employers must provide safeguards, including opportunities for individuals to challenge significant automated decisions and request human oversight. Leanne Fitzmaurice from Purple HR, a Breathe partner, explains:
“You still need human verification to review the AI-generated material. Whoever reviews [the AI] will need to know what they’re looking at, and to double check all the information is correct. But AI can certainly create a framework for you.”
Maintaining your underlying data
The information that an AI assistant provides will only ever be as accurate as the information you feed into it, which depends on the quality of your company’s HR documents. If your records are incomplete or inaccurate, employees could receive incorrect answers without realising there's a problem.
For example, if an employee asks about their remaining holiday allowance but your records don't reflect their latest time-off requests, the AI could give them the wrong balance.
How to use AI responsibly in your HR processes
Whether you're already experimenting with AI or using it regularly, implementing AI responsibly means understanding where it can help while making sure people stay in control of how they use it. These five steps can help you get all of the value AI promises while protecting your employees and your business.
1. Be clear about what AI can help with
Decide which HR tasks are suitable for AI and which need a more personal approach. Drafting routine communications or finding information in company policies can be good uses, but human team members should always handle sensitive employee conversations.
Make sure managers understand the best places AI can support their work without taking over their responsibilities.
2. Use approved AI tools
Employees may already be using tools like ChatGPT to help with everyday work, but that doesn't mean every tool is suitable for HR.
Check which AI tools your business currently uses and whether they're appropriate for handling HR information. As you're adopting AI across more tasks, agree on a shortlist of approved tools so your team knows which platforms they can safely use.
3. Set rules for sharing employee information
Explain what employees and managers can safely enter into AI tools. For example, they might use AI to draft a generic performance review template, but shouldn't upload an employee's completed appraisal into an unapproved platform.
Make sure your guidelines reflect your responsibilities under UK GDPR and the way your chosen tools handle personal data.
4. Keep people in control of important decisions
AI can help managers prepare for HR decisions, but shouldn't be treated as the final authority on someone's employment.
Require managers to review AI-generated recommendations, check the supporting information and consider the individual circumstances before acting. Pay particular attention to decisions about recruitment or disciplinary matters, where mistakes could have serious consequences.
5. Review how AI is working for your team
Check whether your AI tools are delivering the benefits you expected. Ask:
-
Are employees finding the answers they need?
-
Is the information accurate?
-
Are managers spending less time on routine HR tasks?
Encourage your team to flag incorrect answers or concerns about how AI is being used. Use their feedback to improve your guidelines and review your approach to AI adoption as your team becomes more familiar with the technology.
Make everyday HR brilliantly simple with Breathe
At Breathe, we're making everyday HR easier for small businesses with our AI-first HR software. Our AI Assistant helps your employees find the information they need and gives you more time to focus on your people. Here's how Breathe can help:
-
Give employees instant answers: Let your team ask questions about your company policies in their words, with the answers based on your HR documents.
-
Cut down on repetitive HR questions: Let employees find the information they need for themselves.
-
Keep HR information in one place: Store employee records and company documents securely, so your team has a reliable place to find important information.
-
Simplify everyday HR admin: Manage holiday requests, rota planning, performance reviews, training, and other essential HR tasks through Breathe's easy-to-use platform.
With Breathe, you can spend less time on HR admin and more time making your business brilliant. Ready to make HR brilliantly simple? Start your free Breathe trial.
FAQs about artificial intelligence for small business HR
What HR tasks can AI automate?
AI can automate or simplify routine HR tasks such as drafting employee communications, answering common policy questions and finding information in HR documents. More advanced AI tools can coordinate activities like recruitment and onboarding. However you choose to work with AI, remember that humans should always be in charge of making important decisions that affect your people.
Can AI help small businesses with employment law?
Yes, AI can help small businesses understand UK employment law by explaining any unfamiliar terminology and summarising guidance. AI can make mistakes or rely on outdated legislation, so always check its answers against current guidance from Acas or GOV.UK. And for complex employment questions, it’s important to seek professional HR or legal advice. Breathe’s partner directory lets you browse 1,000+ consultants based on location and specific services to find the right support.
Is it safe to use AI for HR?
Yes, AI can be safe to use for HR, so long as you choose appropriate tools and protect employees' personal information. To do so, check how providers store and process data, follow UK GDPR requirements and avoid entering confidential employee details into unapproved platforms. You should also review AI-generated answers before relying on them.
Will AI replace HR professionals?
No, AI is unlikely to replace HR professionals entirely because managing people requires human skills like empathy and human judgment. While AI can take care of repetitive admin and help employees find information, HR professionals should always be responsible for sensitive conversations and important employment decisions. For small businesses, AI is best as an extra helping hand rather than a replacement for people.